Why do many Hindus view Tantrism as evil?

Tantrism (aka Tantric yoga or just Tantra) is often perceived as evil because, at least in premodern times, Tantrikas were seen as sorcerors, and many tantras were seen as instructions for performing black magic: rituals to gather or manipulate supernatural power in order to harm others.

Consider Prof. Judit Torzsok's translation of the Siddhayogesvarımata, a medieval compendium of Tantric rites, and her analysis of the supernatural powers (siddhis) they were supposed to achieve:

       1. sdttvika siddhis: well-being / being well-fed (pusti I dpydyana); expiation / pacification (sdnti); [saving things] in case some disaster occurs (upasarge samut-panne); conquering death (mrtyumjaya); eloquence / poetic talent (kavitva); the ability to be infinitely small, big etc. (animddigundh); final release (moksa).
       2. rdjasa siddhis: subjugating people to one's will (vasyd); attracting people (esp. women, dkarsana); going to the underworld (pdtdlecaratvam); flying (khe-caratvam); disappearing (antardhdnam); "pill-siddhi" (a pill, put in the mouth, is said to make one invisible, gulikdsiddhi); and a siddhi with a magic wand and a bowl (siddhakdsthakamandalau).
       3. tdmasa siddhis, twelve kinds of black magic (abhicdras) listed in chapter 24: murder (mdrana), expelling someone (uccdtana), annihilation (jambhana), 
paralysing (stambhana), benumbing (mohana), "nailing down" (kllana), taking away someone's speech (vdcdpahdra), making someone dumb (mukatva), deaf (bddhirya), blind (andhana), impotent (sandhlkarana), and changing one's form (rupasya parivartanam) (Torzsok 2000: 138-139).
[As quoted in "Genesis and Development of Tantra"]

Evil Goals...

Some of the goals of Tantric spells are found in any religion, including the Vedic tradition in Hinduism. People everywhere pray to their gods or guardian spirits for protection from hunger, violence, disaster, disease, and premature death. People also pray for good things, to be rich, smart, and talented, and to attract the opposite sex. But a lot of the appeal of Tantra was its claim to be able to gratify far more antisocial desires, to give practitioners magical powers that would enable them to kill, subjugate, seduce, and harm other people.

Other Tantric collections show the same pattern as the Siddhayogesvarımata, with a handful of spiritual or beneficial objectives, and a lot of aggressive, offensive, and anti-social ones. Antisocial or sorcerous objectives are not unknown in Vedic rites, but the emphasis changes dramatically as Prof. Shingo Einoo has shown in a meticulous analysis of Vedic sources, specifically the Rgvidhana and the Samavidhanabrahmana, and the kamya rites given in the Gobhilagrhyasutra, which he compares to the Vınasikhatantra, a Hindu Tantric text, and the Amoghapasakalparaja, a Buddhist Tantric text. The Vedic sources include occasional and fairly innocuous mentions of sorcerous goals. In both Tantric sources, however, the emphasis shifts substantially toward sorcery and black magic. (See: Genesis and Development of Tantra.)


...and Evil Means

Tantrism also had a reputation for evil because of the means it used. A Vedic ritual for long life might be: "Purify your mind and recite these four verses ten times while making an offering of butter in a fire," whereas a Tantric ritual to gain sorcerous powers would involve things like blood sacrifice of animals, eating meat, drinking wine or menstrual blood, and having sex on top of a corpse at midnight. The tantric rite is therefore obviously going to be perceived as being a more powerful kind of magic, but also one that violates many, many social norms.

There has been a tendency in the last 200 years for high-minded Hindus and Buddhists to deny that Tantric rites were ever performed, or were ever even intended to be performed, as written. These apologists claim that the Tantric rites were some kind of code for spiritual practices, to be performed in the imagination only, and that they were harmless rituals intended to help practitioners reach spiritual enlightenment. However, few, if any, serious scholars who have examined the relevant written tantras from that period conclude that they were anything other than literal instructions for the performance of sorcery and black magic.

The Tantric practices performed and discussed in public today are a highly sanitized shadow of their old forms, and many modern practitioners will insist that Tantra is just an outward and earthly path to enlightenment, a benign alternative to the inward, ascetic path. But if you look in the shadows, you can still find plenty of people willing to teach you the old black magic. So the question is whether Tantra has truly changed, or has simply gone back underground, as it has often done before when it was out of favor.

Incidentally, Westerners who think of yogis as benevolent, or at least contemplative, holy men, should read Sinister Yogis, David Gordon White's investigation of the historical record. It's part of his excellent three volume series on the origins and development of the Tantric traditions that are found in all Asian religions, including: The Alchemical Body: Siddha Traditions in Medieval India and Kiss of the Yogini: "Tantric Sex" in its South Asian Contexts. These are serious, scholarly works of history and philology, not popular books, so they are heavy going (sometimes very heavy), but they are worth the hard slog if you are interested in the subject.

Modern Tantrism

Tantrism is alive and well as a major element within Hinduism, no matter how much "civilized" Hindus might like to deny it. It is considered disreputable and even shameful by many, but it is still practiced, and many villagers spend scarce rupees for spells, charms, and even curses. Tantric "healers" and wizards do a thriving business within most Hindu temples.

Many people in India still believe, or claim to believe, in the old black magic, or "tantra mantra" as it is often called. As an illustration, try doing this Google search:

site:www.reddit.com/ "tantra" +"91"

Reddit is a social media site and "91" is the country code for India, so this is a very general search for posts that mention tantra and an Indian phone number. Just now I came up with 124 unique posts after eliminating duplicates, all advertising black magic, spell casting, or spell removal services. There appeared to be at least 12 different "tantric sorcerers" offering a wide variety of charms, spells, and services, such as this prolific outfit:
+91-7740834666 KaLa jadu SpeciaLiST BaBa ji TaNTRa MaNTRa In UAE - BangaLore
““{{}}”““+91-7740834666”““{}”““Jadu tantra mantra in Raipur
+91-7740834666 Black magic spells removal Aghori tantra spells vidya in Peterborough [with duplicate posts for many other cities and countries]
+91-7740834666 How to get rid of tantra effect destroy enemy ,By{ No 1 guru ji } in Kuwait [with duplicate posts for many other cities and countries]
~~!!@@~~+91-7740834666~~!!@@~~Tantra spells black magic specialist in Florence [with duplicate posts for many other cities and countries]
+91-7740834666(´ ✖﹏✖) Attract spells aghori tantra in Zakynthos (´ ✖﹏✖)
 "Attract" spells are love or sex or control spells, usually to be cast on a woman:
+91-9694102888 Attraction mantra aghori tantra in Switzerland [with duplicates for many other cities and countries]
But why mess around? Let's get to the real black magic:
+91-9914703222**//tantra mantra black magic specialist baba ji Ranchi
+91-8690127973 Muslim Black Magic for Islamic Tantra Mantra Molvi baba ji in Macau, Macedonia, Madagascar, Malawi, Malaysia, Maldives, Mali, Malta, ...
+91-9876425548"NO. 1(Astrologer) Does Tantra- shiv sadhna really effect the targeted person in London [with duplicate posts for many other cities and countries]
+91-9876425548" NO. 1(Astrologer) How to get rid of tantra effect destroy enemy, in Dubai [with duplicate posts for many other cities and countries]
+91-9680118734 Black magic removal spells & Remove remedy tantra aghora!
Black magic removal tantra Molvi ji +91 8690127973 : u/molviji555
Many of the longer promos are in Hindi, but we have Google Translate to the rescue! Sometimes the results almost make sense:
Bhairav ​​Tantra Sadhana + 91-7727803956, The Ashtami of the Krishna side of the Kartik month is known as Kaal Bhairav ​​Ashtami. According to the scriptures, Bhairav ​​was born this eighth century. By worshiping Bhairav ​​on this day, all the suffering in life comes away. On Bhairav ​​Ashtami, Bhairav ​​must visit his temple. Kaal Bhairav ​​is the law of meditation and performing their special pooja in the night.
Bhaairav ​​Tantra Sadhana + 91-7727803956,
Burn the mustard oil lamp in the north. Sit and sit in front of the red seat. Now take some water in your hand and take a resolution and start chanting mantra. Do this sadhana continuously for 41 days. After 41 days, the chants you have done in these days have been done by offering sacrifices of tenth part of them.
That sounds like a lot of work, but maybe it would be worth it to get rid of "all the suffering in life"!

What about this pair?
Bengali tantra mantra + 91-9660890721, if someone has to subdue, take three leaves and invite paan by the mantra, should be cleaned to invite the bath 21 times chanting When you want to eat the first leaf, give him time to eat and drink it. He will become a friend of you. On the second page, he will make a sexual relationship with you, and if he gets the third leaf, he will be able to join you like this. It will never be far away, you will be left alone.
Bengali tantra mantra + 91-9660890721 If there is any kind of obstacle in your marriage business, it is repeatedly failing and you have been disturbed by the failure of the gesture, then make the old wheat flour in the mustard oil and make the Pu Put the night at the crossroads, and saying that I am leaving my misfortune, and do not look back and look back. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q3dnmGWMnXg&feature=youtu.be
Um. Okay. Maybe it lost something in translation. However, it's my favorite because of the video, which includes some really hokey images meant to convey the idea of powerful sorcery:




If skulls, candles, dreadlocks, and skeletal arms don't do it for you, let's throw in a pentagram, a grimoire, and a voodoo doll getting stuck with pins! Because who cares whether any of this is authentic tantra, as long as it's scary and magical, right?  :)

Another one that still seems garbled after translation:
Shiv Tantra Sadhana-शिव तंत्र साधना Contact/Whatsapp +91-9982368245, If the Shiv Tantra Sadhana-Shiva Tantra is practiced in odd and vulnerable situations, then difficult obstacles are liberated. Removing any major problem and disconnection can threaten to happen forever. Sincerely, Shiv Tantra Sadhana-Shiva Tantra should be done by giving the letter of the letter on Shivling, by giving water to the devotees. Shiv Tantra Sadhana- Shiva Tantra is to be done through sadhana, it is necessary to do the work of the door, to worship it. -Siddhi and Mantr-jaap are the only people who have left the job. The word "Shiva Swarup" This is the only word to say. Swami Vishambhar Das 
I'm not sure what Muslim astrologers have to do with tantra, but these posts showed up in the same search, so presumably Google thinks "muslim astrologer" is a synonym for "tantra":
786 Muslim Astrologer/ WORLD NO.1 POWERFUL BEST INDIAN ASTROLOGER MOLVI JI..09829916185
Get all solutions in your life within 72 hours and with Molvi ji full 500% guaranteed. With in astrology systematic call to 09829916185 and get advice from him.
Any problems.vashikaran specialist molvi ji give highly remedies for love marriage, vashikaran, black magic, to get your love back again in life etc.
Vashikaran is a power by which one man/woman can attract anyone in life,,and that body will do as you say. by help of vashikaran astrology you can get all things in life
famous muslim astrologer india nahrad shrif dargah mohomad jakir ali +91 9521481542
100% solution any problem get solution with in 24 hour one call cen solve your all
problem by muslim astrology molana jakir ali
((((our services))))
Love marriage specialist MOLVI JI
Solve my love problem MOLVI JI
Best Muslim Astrologer MOLVI JI
Wazaif for Marriage MOLVI JI
If you do the search I linked above, you'll get different results depending on when you do it, so you may find some new gems of your own.

Do people in India today really believe that black magic works? Some don't, but apparently many still do. Quora, for some reason, is very popular in India, and it routinely features questions and answers about tantra as black magic, like this one:

"Does Tantra-Mantra really effect the targeted person and what effect does it has on the person trying it?"


Answered by "Virendra Kumar Sharma, studied at University of Delhi":
Tantra is the Vidhya- It has always quick response effects and if it is targeted to particular person or place is effected without any delay. Tantra Vidhya or some noted reciting Kriya is done by some Aughor- and noted Siddha Ojha or Bhut- Pret-Pisach adoring people. It is not for all common people. It is done by some Ojha and Aughar- who commands some Bhut- Pret- Pisach-Chudel and others dreaded souls always under his own commands.
By Tantra Vidhya, Aughar or Tantric can even kill or harass any common person or whatever, he wishes. There are so many such examples, where Tantric has done black magic on particular woman, and particular person and they were harassed and their property and business are lost totally. There are so many people in west Bengal-Bihar and even in Assam, who are addicted to Tantra Vidhya. There is example which I heard by people that By Tantra reciting Mantra, a serpent cobra bitten dead person is came to life after some days of his death. There are so many such examples, when child or people were killed untimely due to black magic by Tantric. Bengal is most famous place for Tantra or Black magic. 
By Tantra Vidhya, Tantric can even change your life from poverty to richness also is also most important quality. But the formula and rules are very hard, because it is done, just ignoring your destiny of Lord Brahma JI. If the person did not follow the rules of Tantric, it can be most tough task for yourself also, in case, it is ignored. So, it has negative effects are large always. One should avoid it. It is against the supreme Lord creation which one has to suffer one day also.
Ummmm ... "There is example which I heard by people that By Tantra reciting Mantra, a serpent cobra bitten dead person is came to life after some days of his death. There are so many such examples, when child or people were killed untimely due to black magic by Tantric."

Really???

Belief is one thing. Proof is quite another. For a hilarious and very public failure of tantric "sorcery" in modern times, read this account of a dead serious attempt to kill a person with tantric magic on national TV: The Great Tantra Challenge.

Tantric Sex

If you're wondering what, if anything, all of this has to do with "tantric sex," in the modern Western sense of the term, the answer is, almost nothing. But that's most of what the rest of this blog is about. Here's a good place to start:

What is Tantric Sex?

Or click the "Welcome" tab at the top of the page if you actually want to learn how to do it. I assure you there's no black magic involved and the goals and methods are purely benevolent! :)

No comments:

Post a Comment